Fifth Circuit Reinstates Nasdaq Board Diversity Rule Challenge — A New Test for SEC Deference
Fifth Circuit Reinstates Nasdaq Board Diversity Rule Challenge — A New Test for SEC Deference A federal appeals court has revived a constitutional challenge to Nasdaq's board diversity disclosure rule
Fifth Circuit Reinstates Nasdaq Board Diversity Rule Challenge — A New Test for SEC Deference
A federal appeals court has revived a constitutional challenge to Nasdaq's board diversity disclosure rule, giving critics of the SEC's approval a fresh hearing and putting the agency's rulemaking deference back under the microscope.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit agreed to rehear the case en banc after a three-judge panel had earlier declined to disturb the SEC's 2021 approval of Nasdaq's "comply or explain" framework. That framework requires listed companies to disclose board-level diversity statistics and, generally, to have at least one director who self-identifies as female and one who self-identifies as an underrepresented minority — or explain why they do not.
The challengers, represented by the Alliance for Fair Board Recruitment and the National Center for Public Policy Research, argue the SEC exceeded its authority under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 when it approved the exchange rule, and that the disclosure mandate compels speech in violation of the First Amendment. The en banc posture matters: the full court is more likely to scrutinize the agency's reasoning than a panel bound by prior deference precedents.
The case lands amid a broader reworking of administrative deference. In Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), the Supreme Court ended Chevron deference, and courts have since been re-examining agency approvals of private exchange rules — a hybrid category where the SEC's sign-off effectively gives a private actor's listing standard the force of federal regulation.
What to watch: whether the en banc court treats Nasdaq's rule as a straightforward exchange listing standard or as substantive federal speech regulation, and whether the SEC's approval order survives without deference. A ruling against the SEC would not automatically void the rule, but it would likely force the agency to re-approve it on a sturdier record — or prompt Nasdaq to amend the framework. Either outcome would ripple through every exchange that has adopted similar disclosure standards.
Primary sources: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit; SEC Order Approving Nasdaq Rule 5605(f) (Release No. 34-92590); Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. ___ (2024)
FedKite Wire
Keep Reading
D.C. Federal Judge Issues Opinion in Long-Running NACDL Records Fight With Bureau of Prisons
D.C. Federal Judge Issues Opinion in Long-Running NACDL Records Fight With Bureau of Prisons Judge Jia M. Cobb of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia issued a memorandum opinion and

Inyo County v. Paiute-Shoshone: When a Tribe's Sovereignty Met a County's Subpoena
The 2003 Supreme Court decision that tested the boundaries of tribal sovereign immunity against state investigative power — argued by John D. Kirby.

Qualified Immunity: The Refinement That Never Happened — and Why It Still Matters
Three decades ago, a Cornell law student proposed a functional test for qualified immunity. The Supreme Court still hasn't adopted it. The lower courts are starting to.