Fifth Circuit Rejects En Banc Review of Warrantless Cell-Phone Tracking, Setting Up Circuit Split
Fifth Circuit Rejects En Banc Review of Warrantless Cell-Phone Tracking, Setting Up Circuit Split A divided Fifth Circuit has declined to rehear a case challenging warrantless cell-site location data
Fifth Circuit Rejects En Banc Review of Warrantless Cell-Phone Tracking, Setting Up Circuit Split
A divided Fifth Circuit has declined to rehear a case challenging warrantless cell-site location data collection, leaving in place a panel ruling that deepens a split among federal appeals courts over whether the Fourth Amendment protects long-term location records.
The underlying case, United States v. Smith, involved investigators who obtained more than six months of historical cell-site location information (CSLI) without a warrant. A three-judge panel upheld the evidence under the good-faith exception, reasoning that binding Fifth Circuit precedent at the time permitted the practice. The full court's refusal to revisit that holding means the panel decision stands.
The Fifth Circuit's position stands in contrast to the Fourth Circuit's 2024 decision in United States v. Trader, which held that a warrant is required for extended CSLI collection. The D.C. Circuit reached a similar conclusion in its 2023 ruling in United States v. Jackson. Those courts relied on Carpenter v. United States, the 2018 Supreme Court decision that established a reasonable expectation of privacy in seven days or more of CSLI.
What makes the Fifth Circuit's approach notable is its reliance on the good-faith exception rather than resolving the constitutional question directly. That leaves the underlying issue — whether the Fifth Circuit's pre-Carpenter precedent remains valid — unresolved for future cases where officers cannot claim good-faith reliance on superseded law.
Practitioners should watch for two developments: whether the government seeks Supreme Court review in the next term, and whether district courts within the Fifth Circuit begin distinguishing the panel's good-faith rationale in cases involving shorter collection periods. The circuit split now covers three circuits on opposite sides, a configuration that historically invites certiorari.
Primary sources: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit; Supreme Court of the United States; Carpenter v. United States, 585 U.S. 296 (2018)
FedKite Wire
Keep Reading
D.C. Federal Judge Issues Opinion in Long-Running NACDL Records Fight With Bureau of Prisons
D.C. Federal Judge Issues Opinion in Long-Running NACDL Records Fight With Bureau of Prisons Judge Jia M. Cobb of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia issued a memorandum opinion and

Inyo County v. Paiute-Shoshone: When a Tribe's Sovereignty Met a County's Subpoena
The 2003 Supreme Court decision that tested the boundaries of tribal sovereign immunity against state investigative power — argued by John D. Kirby.

Qualified Immunity: The Refinement That Never Happened — and Why It Still Matters
Three decades ago, a Cornell law student proposed a functional test for qualified immunity. The Supreme Court still hasn't adopted it. The lower courts are starting to.